Biography: Marian Breland Bailey (1920
– 2001)
Marian Breland Bailey was a pioneer of applied animal psychology and an
international figure in the history of psychology. Known as “Mouse” to her
friends, she and her first husband, Keller Breland, studied under B. F. Skinner
at the University of Minnesota in the late 1930s and early 1940s. So confident
were they in the power of the operant technology, they left graduate school
before obtaining their Ph.D.s and began Animal Behavior Enterprises (ABE), a
commercial venture based on the conditioning of animal behavior through positive
reinforcement.
As an undergraduate, she was a student in one of Skinner’s psychology
seminars. This course was the beginning of a long collaboration and friendship
with Skinner. She proofed the galleys of The Behavior of Organisms (1938), and she transcribed his lectures on the psychology of literature, which
eventually became Verbal Behavior (1957). In 1941, she married Keller Breland, one of Skinner’s graduate students, and she began the fall 1941
semester as a graduate student in Skinner’s lab. One afternoon in the early
1940s, the Brelands suddenly realized how powerful operant procedures could be
when they witnessed Skinner shape the pecking behavior of a pigeon during the
famous “Pigeon in a Pelican” project. This remarkable project was Skinner’s
wartime effort to train pigeons to guide missiles for the U. S. Navy.
The Brelands began ABE in 1947 on their farm in Mound, Minnesota. Their first
programs were for General Mills feed products, in which they trained General
Mills employees to conduct exhibits such as the dancing chicken, the
piano-playing chicken, and the chicken that played the three-shell game (Marian
had a fondness for chickens all her life – she claimed they showed a lot of
variability of behavior that could be selected through reinforcement, and they
were humorous animals when placed in anthropomorphic settings). By 1951, the Brelands were so successful that they were able to describe their many business
undertakings in an American Psychologist article, "A New Field of Applied
Animal Psychology."
In 1951, the Brelands moved to Hot Springs, Arkansas, and in 1955 opened the IQ Zoo. A
major tourist attraction for many years, the IQ Zoo housed chickens that walked
tightropes, dispensed souvenirs to paying customers, danced to music from
jukeboxes, and played baseball. Rabbits kissed their girlfriends, rode fire
trucks, sounded sirens, and rolled wheels of fortune for lucky customers. Ducks
played drums and pianos, while raccoons played basketball.
She and Keller established many firsts across the nation – they were the
first to establish a whale show in 1957 and a combined whale-dolphin show in
1959. They were also the first to do a cat commercial. In the 1950s, they taught
a cat to “behave appropriately” during the filming of a Puss-n-Boots cat-food
commercial. Marian reported they were asked to replace another trainer after the
cat refused to cooperate, had torn the studio to shreds, and “had terrorized the
cameraman.” She once reported (with a slight smile), “Cats do not like to wear
boots."
The Brelands were best known to psychologists for their 1961 article, “The
Misbehavior of Organisms,” in the American Psychologist. The article was
based on the “misbehavior” of animals they observed mostly in the state of
Arkansas -- a pig taught to deposit large wooden nickels in a giant piggy bank
delayed reinforcement by rooting at the coins and tossing them in the air, a
chicken taught to dispense souvenirs began smashing them with its beak, and a
raccoon trained to dispense capsules washed them as if they were food. Turning
to the work of the ethologists Lorenz and Tinbergen, the Brelands questioned a
tabula rasa approach to animal learning and spoke of instinctive drift and the
natural behaviors of species.
When Keller died in 1965, Marian became president of ABE. In 1976, she married
Bob Bailey, a zoologist and chemist. Bob had been director of marine mammal
training for the Navy. With Bob, she began many fascinating projects on animal
intelligence. The work of Marian Breland Bailey extended far beyond the confines
of the IQ Zoo, and most psychologists in Arkansas are unaware that her work
involved projects in many different countries. With Bob Bailey, she studied
dolphin acoustics and communication and animal husbandry techniques (e.g.,
having dolphins cooperate with EKG, ultrasound, and other laboratory
procedures), as well as teaching dolphins to assist deep-sea divers. The Baileys
were able to control cats “at a distance” with radio signals, condition herring
gulls to conduct 360o searches over lakes and oceans, teach pigeons
to fly along a road to spot snipers, and condition ravens to take “intelligence”
photographs with small cameras held in their beaks.
At its height, ABE employed over 40 persons. With her staff, Marian applied
operant conditioning to 150 species, including dolphins, birds, chickens,
rabbits, ducks, cattle, sheep, goats, pigs, dogs, cats, whales, and raccoons.
ABE’s commercial clients included U.S. theme parks (Knott’s Berry Farm,
Opryland, and Six Flags), oceanariums (Marineland of Florida and the Pacific,
Marinelife, and ABC Marineland), and large companies (General Mills, Mobil Oil,
and Quaker Oats). ABE animals made appearances on Wild Kingdom, CBS News, and
the Today, Tonight, and Tomorrow Shows, and were described in articles for Time, Life, the Wall Street Journal, and Reader’s Digest.
One of the most recognized acts produced by the Baileys was Bird Brain, the
Tic-Tac-Toe playing chicken (it would play the game with any paying customer).
The chicken never lost. In 1999, the noted New Yorker writer, Calvin
Trillin, described this remarkable act (and Trillin’s fondness for the bird) in
a charming piece, “The Chicken Vanishes.”
Marian was also a pioneer in the application of behavior modification
procedures to improve the lives of persons with mental retardation. In the
1960s, she collaborated with Gerard Bensberg, training persons with mental
retardation by using reinforcement therapy. In 1965, she published a landmark
chapter on this process in the book Training the Mentally Retarded.
Thirty-one years after leaving the University of Minnesota, she completed her
doctorate at the University of Arkansas. With Jack Marr as her chair, she
completed a dissertation on the acuity of avian vision (concluding that ravens
can see small objects the distance of two football fields). In 1980, Bob and
Marian published a paper on their collaboration, “A View from Outside the
Skinner Box” for the American Psychologist.
She then began teaching at Henderson State University (HSU), where she
developed a Verbal Behavior course based on the very lectures she transcribed as
a young woman. At HSU she was known for her compassion and frequent (as well as
legendary) chicken-training demonstrations. In 1998 she retired at age 78 as
Full Professor.
She did not remain “retired” for long – in the 1990s, Marian and Bob had
already embarked on a project to interview the leaders in the field of operant
and animal behavior. Traveling to many states, they interviewed over 150
professionals in the field. Bob would videotape while Marian interviewed. These
videotapes make a remarkable contribution to the history of psychology,
particularly behavior analysis.
Until a month before her death, Marian traveled with
Bob throughout the United
States, conducting workshops and training students. They hauled a trailer loaded
with chickens from state to state, training students (and their professors), zoo
personnel, veterinarians, pet owners, dolphin trainers, and service animal
trainers. They were planning additional training seminars in Hot Springs when
Marian was hospitalized.
Marian was beloved by all of us in psychology who had a chance to work with
her. She was a modest person, despite her many triumphs and awards (she and Bob
received the Lifetime Achievement Award from the Arkansas Psychological
Association in 1995). She was a kind and understanding person, as well as a
brilliant and persuasive advocate of behavioral technology. She seemed the very
reification of “positive reinforcement.” She is survived by her husband, Bob
Bailey, and children Bradley Breland, Elizabeth Breland, Bob Bailey, Jr., Lynn Bailey, Rae Barriner, Kimmy Bailey Mauldin, and
Ken Bailey, as well as five grandchildren and two great-grandchildren. Her place
in the pantheon of psychology is assured.
[Back]